.

Wednesday, January 23, 2013

Compare And Contrast Accounts Of The After Life By Homer, Plato, And Vergil

MYTHOLOGYHecate : a divinity of the Underworld and companion of Perseph 1 , is called the queen of iniquity and the divinity fudgedess of the cross-roads her troika faces atomic number 18 turned towards as homosexualy directions , and her divulge was shrieked at night at the cross-roads of cities Maenads : These ar the pursual of Dionysus , the graven image of wine-colored . They carry his symbol , the thyrsos , a provide that is cr avowed with ivy , and wear panther skins , an animal that he loves for its excitability . The Maenads overly drape snakes over their hair to hark back that genus genus Zeus cr proclaimed Dionysus with snakes after he let him be give away of his thigh Satyrs : Some stories describe them as att final stageants on Dionysus , the god of wine . a nonher(prenominal) stories say these were savages who lived on sure islands , and had deck out suit as spacious as horse tails . When satyrs caught sight of a venture , they would to it , crying aloud , and assaulting the wowork extract pan off : The god of wild nature . He was born with a beard , terrifying his nurse . From this and similar features , such as his goat-feet , he is said to be the god of irrational terrors (panicPan equalwise play a flute or set of pipes , competing with Apollo s lyre though non bettering that god topland : She had witness so droll that men worshiped her Aphrodite , out of jealousy , sent concupiscence to unsex her fall in love with a unworthy man . Psyche was carried by the wind to a castle , where sexual desire secretly visited her every night . Psyche managed to mold that Eros was her lover , and Psyche suffered Aphrodite 92s wrath . But after complications , the lovers were rejoined , and Psyche was made immortal Mythology Page Arachne : She was famous for her skill in weaving , and fifty-fiftytually challenged the goddess A indeeda to a contest . The goddess became so enraged that she turned the woman into a spider genus A paste : An different name for Athena Athena : The goddess of wisdom , she was non born in any conventional way alternatively , Zeus suffered a headache so terrible that he finally Hephaestus , the god of the smith , to smash him on the head with a hammer . Athena burst forth full counterfeited . She is alike the patron goddess of Athens Artemis : the goddess of the hunt . When the gl atomic number 18enics killed adept of her scared stags on their way to troy weight , she turned the winds against them and appointive that they could sail on exclusively if Agamemnon sacrificed his daughter Ipheginia to her . By obeying this didactics , Agamemnon incurred the wrath of his wife , Clytemnestra Apollo : The god of the sun , who every twenty-four hours drives his flaming chariot across the sky . He is also the god of plagues , which he delivers with his bow , which is menti whizd in the opening of AlcestisHermes : The courier of the gods , who flies about on his winged sandals . He is also the god of the household , so that virtually every Hellenic house had a statue of Hermes in the first place which they made small sacrificesAphrodite : The goddess of beauty . Paris chose her as the nearly beautiful of the goddesses , setting the symbolize for the Trojan contend Dionysus : The god of wine , ecstacy , and savagery . He is whizz of the lesser gods , because his pose was a mortal , even though he is a give-and-take of Zeus Demeter : The make goddess , the goddess of the harvest . When her daughter Proserpine was kidnaped and fetchn into the underworld , she went into such fits of heartbreak that the earth began to wither . Finally , the gods restore her daughter to her , for at least a part of the twelvemonth . But because Proserpine had eaten in Hades , she is required to present in that respect several months of to from distributively matchless one year , and during that time , Demeter mourns again and the earth endures its barren eon Hades : The lord of the underworld , the god of death and repulsiveness . After the overthrow of Cronus , he and his brothers , Poseidon and Zeus , drew practically , and he lost the heavens and the seas in the draw . He is forever concerned with increa sineg his subjects , so that the dead cannister never leave his solid ground . He is also the god of wealth , hence the word 93plutocracy 94 regulation by a wealthy elite1 .Virgil gives the most complete of the afterlife , in the business leaderdom of Dis . Led by the Sibyl of Cumae , Aeneas enters Dis and finds the River Acheron . hither , Charon ferries the dead , although he refuses to take those whose corpses had non been given proper burial . ON the other side of this river , Aeneas hears the wailing of excruciation nouss as inspirit latterly dead stand before Minos for judgmentAeneas sees the field of heroes of the Trojan fight , and passes the grim fortress where Rhadamanthus metes out judgments upon the worst sinners Finally , Aeneas and the Sibyl seeded player to the Blessed Groves , where the true(p) enjoy peace and comfort . Here Aeneas sees his father , who explains how the dead are dispersed in Dis and how faithful psyches can eventually area the Fields of Gladness . He then explains what Aeneas 92 lineage will do in Italy . From his posterity , Romulus will found Rome , Ascanius line will explicate Caesar , and Rome will reach a Golden era of world subordination . Aeneas now understands why he is in Italy and returns to the surface world ready to carry onVirgil 92s Dis represents a super developed statement of classical theology , which was stillness in development at the time he wrote . In a world of temperamental and often arbitrary gods , Virgil 92s afterlife gives judgments base on the jurist of one 92s life . This concept parallels rescuerian and Judaic tradition that would develop several centuries later . In this passage , Virgil drew on classical Orphic mysteries . Orpheus , the 93priest of Thrace 94 is in the Blessed GrovesOrphism was also a source for Plato 92s views of the afterlifeRhadamanthus judgments of souls resembles the Christian invention of judgment : those who do not repent on populace are doomed in Hell . A mention difference is the absence of any heaven . All souls go to Dis the good souls merely get better portions within this sanatorium . Arguably , this scheme fits Christian theology , which postulated that before Christ 92s death and resurrection , all souls were relegated to Hell , so that even the souls of the pure(a) were in Hell until Christ resurrectionNotably , in this underworld , of the gods that rule on the earth appear to gain any battlefront . Radamanthus , Minos , and even Charon , rule with minimal interference from deities that hold sway aboveIn password 11 , of the Odyssey , Odysseus steers his ship to the River of Ocean , and is able to reach the dark metropolis of the Cimmereans . Here he follows Circe 92s instructions to commit the souls of the dead Notably , he does not so frequently go into the underworld as he stands at one of its portals where the spirits of the dead come to himHis comrade Elpenor begs Odysseus to return to Circe 92s island to his bole a proper burial . Clearly Elpenor is suffering , nevertheless mark does not give us any specifics about this . The Theban prophet Tiresias reveals that Poseidon is punishing the Achaeans for blinding Polyphemus , and warns Odysseus of his fate , that he will reach home to reclaim Penelope from the scummy suitors , and then make another voyage to appease Poseidon . He also warns Odysseus not to touch the flocks of the SunOdysseus calls forth other spirits . He speaks with his mother Anticleia , who tells him of affairs in Ithaca and of how she died of grief wait for him . He then checks the spirits of various famous men and heroes and hears the stories of their lives and deaths . Agamemnon tells him of his murder by Clytemnestra . Achilles wants to drive in about his son , Neoptolemus . Odysseus then tries to speak to Ajax , who killed himself after a contest with Odysseus , and Ajax slips taciturnly away . He sees Heracles , Minos , Orion , and others , and witnesses the penaltys of Sisyphus and Tantalus . Odysseus soon finds himself mobbed by souls inquire of relatives in the world above , and becomes frightened , runs back to his ship , and immediately sails awayThese scenes show the reader a range of mythologic lives . Homer 92s audience would have kn stimulate the stories of these figures . By juxtaposing Odysseus 92s wanderings against the woes of these known figures Homer broadens his epic and entrenches his hero in his culture 92s mythology . still that he is allowed to enter Hades shows that Odysseus has a transcendent statusOdysseus 92s confabulation with Achilles reveals a nuanced view of warfare and jubilate . Achilles declares , 93I 92d rather break ones back on earth for another man / than rule slew here over all the breathless dead 94 This alludes to Achilles predicament , mentioned in the Iliad he had to pick mingled with glory in battle dying untested or a long uneventful life . The Iliad celebrates the glory of warfare squareheartedly endorsing Achilles 92 filling of glory over long life But Achilles 92 sorrow in the Odyssey warns against the ethic of glory This change in Achilles from one poem to the other is understandable We have seen with Odysseus that the Odyssey tends to focus on characters 92 inner lives . Yet Achilles doesn 92t wholly shun the idea of glory . Though he turns away somewhat from his warrior ethos , he still rejoices to hear that his son has become a great warriorAppearing near the mid-point of the epic , this segment connects the poem 92s various settings . Anticleia recalls Ithaca . Agamemnon and Achilles echo Troy . Elpenor died on Circe 92s island , recalling Odysseus 92s immediate responsibilities to his crew . And all of this appears in a recounting ta pansy place in the palace of the PhaeaciansNotably , this is a vision of the underworld that encompasses every soul . at that place is no 93better Place 94 to which the virtuous will be elevated , only a world of darkness never brightened by the son , where the best and the worst seem to merit equal treatmentIn Book X of The Republic , Socrates presents his final argument in respect of justice ground on the myth of Er . He challenges to the rewards which the just will receive in the afterlife . gibe to the myth , a warrior named Er was killed in battle , but did not actually die . He went to heaven , and had to fall out everything that happened there , and then was sent back to the earth to fib on his voyage . He observes a system which rewarded celibacy , particularly wisdom . People are granted metre years , in either in heaven as a reward , or in Hell as punishment for the deeds preformed during the earthly life . They then meet in a common area where each soul chooses its next life , either animal or gentle . The life that they choose determines whether they are rewarded or punished in the next cycle . Only those who were philosophic while bouncy learn the trick of how to chose a just life . Odysseus manages this by choosing to be reborn as a swan . Everyone else hurtles in the midst of happiness and misery with every cycleThis Er myth , with its appeal to reward and punishment , represents an argument based on motivations Plato had brush aside earlier in The Republic . Glaucon and Adeimantus had specifically asked him to praise justice without appealing to these circumstanceors . It seems surprising that he reverts to it at the end of the agree . Bloom suggests that the inclusion of this myth is connected to the distinction between philosophical virtue and civic virtue . Philosophical virtue is the kind of virtue the philosopher possesses , and this kind of virtue differs from the virtue of the typical citizen . Arguably Plato had shown only that philosophical virtue is worthy in itself . He had not shown that the worthiness of civic virtue . Because Glaucon and Adeimantus were not capable of philosophical virtue , Plato needed to give them a reason to pursue the virtue that they could achieve . The thousand year cycles of reward and punishment that follow just and unjust lives is think to philosophical virtueThe Er myth shows why philosophy is required . Civic virtues is inadequate by itself . Only philosophers know how to choose the right new life , because only they understand the soul and understand what makes life good or bad . Other souls , wanting such understanding , can only take a chance , so that they flip-flop endlessly fluctuating between good lives and misery . Because every soul moldiness choose its own life , each person is entirely responsibility for his own justice and injustice . A person chooses injustice out of ignorance of what makes is just and what is unjust . Mankind 92s only true sin then is ignorance , and philosophy the only redemptionThis is the least developed of the three plant , and partly this reflects the nature of The Republic . It is a philosophical treatise although it is presented in the form of a multi-character dialogue . By lineage , The Odyssey and The Aeneid are epic poems , aimed primarily at entertainment rather than philosophical instructionThis view of the underworld is also the only one of the three that allows for a soul to eventually rise from Hell . After a thousand years the soul chooses a new life 2 .In umteen ways , The Bacchae is a shocking story . Dionysus was conceived through the union of his mother , Semele , with Zeus . Learning that Semele was pregnant , her family did not believe that Zeus had fathered the child , and accused Semele of lying to cover up a love affair . When Semele was struck by lightning , her family took it as a signal of divine retribution , and proof that the child was merely the product of a human union , They also fancied that the child died with Semele . But the unborn Dionysus had been spirited away , and now grown he has come back , determined to land vengeance on his mother 92s family for their failure to believe in the divinity of his conception He has excited the women of Thebes , who are carrying on in wild bacchanalHe now moves to destroy Pentheus , who is in fact his own cousin , the son of his mother 92s sister . Dionysus entices Pentheus to dress as a woman and to go into the wilderness to extend to watch the women as carry on their revelries . Once there , Dionysus helps Pentheus climb to the top of a tree . He then betrays him . He then lets the women see him They attack Pentheus , with Agave , Pentheus own mother , tearing off his head and returning to the urban center with this trophy impaled on a stickThere is a gruesome personal credit line between the loving God of Christianity and this malevolent deity . Dionysus is peevish , angered that his divinity has not been recognized and accepted by his family and his urban center . But this is his first trip to the city , and the Thebans have only heard about his feasts . Further , he is a god of things that need to be held in check : wine , revelry , ecstacy , and savagery , characteristics that can be summed up in a single and singularly un- Greek word immoderationArguably , Dionysus does precisely what inebriant does : he brings out the hidden tendencies in its users , and modern societies , conscious of the damage these tendencies can wreak on people , sets certain restrictions on the use of alcohol . Dionysus obviously feels that his revelers essential learn of the need for moderation for themselves .
Order your essay at Orderessay and get a 100% original and high-quality custom paper within the required time frame.
He does nothing to warn them of the dangers that they pretend through their revelries , and he seems to take a particular interest in taking advantage of Pentheus 92 youth , inexperience , and brashnessIn many ways , Pentheus and Dionysus present polar opposites in this play , although no pair of these opposites can completely explain this play . and then , one lesson the play offers is that any effort to reduce it to a simple binary view is inadequate . There are sets of many opposing forces here : rationality versus irrationality , Greek versus the foreign , finish versus the wilderness , with Pentheus and Dionysus embodying the opposing forcesWisdom is a call aspect of this drama . Throughout the play , there are wisdom figures : the old blind seer Tiresias , Cadmus the aged patriarch the Maenads of Thebes caught up in their possession , and finally Dionysus himself possessed of a certain kind of divine wisdom . Yet each of these figures has limitations , able to offer some insight , but each denied full understanding . Part of what the play teaches is an awareness of limitationsIn this opine , even the gods have limitations to their wisdom , as Dionysus fully illustrates . He humiliates Pentheus , and finding this is not enough to sate his desires , he has him remove and ripped to shreds , with his own mother tearing his head off and deliverance it back to the city as a trophy . There is a profound if costly wisdom to be gained from this suffering , and clearly it is entirely beyond Dionysus 92 ability to grasp this form of wisdomAlso this a play about reckless king . Pentheus goes beyond the bounds of , bandaging as a woman so that he can on the women 92s revelries . In doing this , he shows a failure to understand the natural and his place in it . He is uppity , impatient , bullying , and crude . He is lumpish about the piety that the Maenads have discovered . Yet if Pentheus is excessive in wanting to watch the revelries , we must ask if Dionysus is not also excessive in the bloody revenge he exacts from Pentheus and AgaveDionysus infects the play with a sense of the sinister . numerous of his followers are not local residents they are Asians , 93the other 94 the exotic , the unknown . Like them , he is new and unfamiliar . He is all of the things that Pentheus wants to reject or ignore . Pentheus insisting on restoring , opposes any worship of Dionysus largely because he cannot comprehend it , most notably failing to see the connection between himself and what Dionysus represents . At the same time , instead of simply leaving the bacchanalia alone , he tries to sample it illicitly by dressing as a womanDionysus also represents virtually everything that the staid Greek held dear and necessary to a sound social . Dionysus gives the women of Thebes divine powers in their ecstatic state . This threatens the social , which Pentheus tries to preserve , an reign by males , while Dionysus seems to be the embodiment of chaos , barbarism androgyny , and unbounded female freedom . Male domination was very much a part of Greek civilization . By endowing the Maenads with supernatural powers and having them break away from their normal national chores Dionysus came close to attacking the foundation of Hellenic civilization . Pentheus is terrified but fascinated by this triumph of women over menIn the end , there is a profound pessimism about this play . Pentheus has not really done enough to show his divinity so as to offer the men of Thebes a reasonable presentation that he is divine . He exacts a terrible punishment on them for not knowing what they could not be pass judgment to know . With craft and skill , he plays on the faults of young Pentheus leading him to his death . His punishment of Agave seems even more than unfair . She has not only lost her son , she has been the unintended means by which he has met his death , and she now must live out her life in the knowledge that she returned to the city bearing his head as a trophy Where is the haunt ? Where can the pious Greek look to demand that Dionysus be made to answer for his excesses ? Nowhere . Part of what this play teaches is that the god of excess can have his excesses while mortals must eer guard against them 3 .The Greek anthropomorphic gods and goddesses were a force for good A great many examples from Greek lit show that the Greeks felt that their lives were interlinked with the lives of their gods and goddesses , and they openly invoked the gods in their belles-lettres . Homer begins The Iliad with the words , 93Sing , Goddess 94 and The Odyssey with 93Tell me , oh , Muse 94In their play , an invocation of the gods is almost a set opening for their dramas . The Bacchae begins with Dionysus appearing to explain his origin and to reveal that has come to deal with Pentheus , who refuses to remark him . At the beginning of Andromeche , Andromeche appears before the temple of Thetis , the divine mother of Achilles . The Agamemnon opens with the watchman , alone on the roof of the palace of his king praying to the gods that some end be brought to the endless task of watching in the night . In Antigone , Antigone insists that her brother must be buried with due honor because this is something that the gods command , and their command overrides any decree that the mortal king Creon , might set down . Suppliants begins with a cry to the gods Oedipus Rex begins with Oedipus demanding to know why the chorus are assembled , and the Priest replying that they have come to plead with the gods to know why a plague has move on their city . Alcestis presents the most open invocation of the gods as Apollo and Death meet together before the palace of Admetus , king on ThessalyOn another level , the plays were all performed at the festival of Dionysus , and by all indications , this festival with its offerings of plays specifically written for these performances was one of the highlights of the life of Athens and other cities . They built theaters to hold audiences of 15 ,000 , which would have amounted to a huge portion of the free citizenship of the city-state , and position the commissioning of plays written for each festivalThese and many other works can be cited for the idea that the Greeks believed in their anthropomorphic gods , cosmos very much like themselves in their feeling , emotions and reactions . Zeus is the king of the gods but often rules over a ruly realm . He looks down on the earth , and openly lusts after the some of the mortals below , In the form of a bull he seduces Europa . In the form of a gargantuan swan , he attacks Leda . Hera the queen of the gods , is a jealous married person , and many of the great tales of Greek lore are based on her rage over her husband 92s dalliances with mortals . The Trojan War comes about when Paris is asked to decide who is should receive the apple impel into an Olympian wedding feast by Eris , the goddess of discord . Offered bribes of power and wisdom by Hera and Athena , he rejects these in choose of the gift that will bring about the doom of his city of Troy : he agrees to give the apple to Aphrodite in return for the most beautiful woman on earth , Helen of TroyMany of the go examples of Greek architecture are their temples and structures such as the Parthenon and the whole Acropolis speak to the aesthetic brilliance of Greek work . Many of the most notable and beautiful modern public buildings and monuments are done in the style of Greek architectureFrom a spiritual standpoint , we now dismiss Zeus , Athena , Ares Neptune , and the like as part of an ancient culture . But we must look back on theat culture with profound awe . From these man-like gods , the Greek managed to drawn inspiration for much of the great literature of the ancient world , and much that is fundamental to many of our finest liberal arts forms we owe to this culture...If you want to get a full essay, sanctify it on our website: Orderessay

If you want to get a full essay, wisit our page: write my essay .

No comments:

Post a Comment